portrait of an angry robot

The US Copyright Office is conducting “a study regarding the copyright issues raised by generative artificial intelligence (AI)” and the public has been invited to submit comments on the matter.

The Office published a notice of inquiry on August 30, 2023. Initial written comments are due by 11:59 p.m. eastern time on October 30, 2023. Reply comments are due by 11:59 p.m. eastern time on November 29, 2023.

US Copyright Office.

The Comment I Submitted:

Copying a writer’s work and utilizing that content without their express permission is an abusive practice that must never be tolerated, much less adopted as a norm.

Attempting to understate the criminality/unfairness of these actions by changing phrasing–from “copied from” to “informed by”, for example–is a complete perversion of the principles of owning the copyright to one’s own work. It is also economically catastrophic and detrimental to human writers and artists.

There is no actual artificial “intelligence” involved here

Computer programs do not presently have the capability to think for themselves or discern right from wrong. Let us please not keep pretending that the technologies being touted at artificial “intelligence” are more than glorified search engines that have the capability to scrape the internet, stealing the product of our creative labors. 

The sad fact is that the technology being called artificial intelligence could be inherently useful to humans but its potential usefulness has been perverted by bad actors attempting to give people the impression that this technology is capable of thinking for itself and producing original content and ideas. It is certainly not. 

Only terrible humans

In reality, all we have here are Terrible Humans seeking to take unfair advantage of and profit unethically from the labors of other humans, i.e. writers, artists, and other creatives, while shifting all responsibility/accountability for their ill-deeds onto non-human entities.

Under no circumstances do I, personally, wish to acquiesce to the selfish kind of sophistry and twisted logic that demands that my creative work is fair game for the use of individuals or corporations bent on profiting obscenely from the product of my labors without fairly compensating me. 

Copying and utilizing my creative work, for any purpose, without my consent—not to mention without properly compensating me for it–is theft. It only stands to reason that such actions/behavior should be strictly prohibited.

Would you like to weigh in on the matter too?

Submit your comment/statement here: https://www.copyright.gov/policy/artificial-intelligence/comment-submission

2 thoughts on “AI “Writing” and “Art” IS Theft & Yes, I’m Willing to Die on This Hill

  1. Mark Richard Hunter

    Seems pretty cut and dry to me.

    1. Tonya R. Moore

      Looks like the WGA came to the same conclusion.

Comment:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recommended Posts

Poster for The Eagle Has Landed documentary featuring Jeffrey Morris (FutureDude) holding a scale model of the eagle fromt he 1970's tv show, Space: 1999.
Interviews

Jeffrey Morris (FutureDude): Living proof that humanity’s pioneering spirit isn’t dead!

Jeffrey Morris is the writer, producer, entrepreneur, and production designer at the helm of Future Dude Entertainment, a premier source for original and captivating, future-focused adventure stories that span genres, media, and generations. I recently got a chance to chat with Jeffrey about The Eagle Has Landed, a documentary featuring

Tonya R. Moore
Photos of authors Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki and Joshua Uchenna Omenga alongside the cover of their book Between Dystopias: The Road to Afropantheology
Interviews

Digging Deeper into Afropantheology’s Roots

I recently had the opportunity to interview Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki and Joshua Uchenna Omenga, the authors of the forthcoming Between Dystopias: The Road to Afropantheology, a collection of short stories and essays examining the lore and and lived experiences comprising the foundations of African speculative fiction.  Two weeks ago, Publishers

Tonya R. Moore

Discover more from Tonya R. Moore

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading